8 of the Best Bourbons for Crafting an Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned is a cocktail that has truly stood the test of time. It’s been a staple in bars and homes since the 19th century, and to this day, remains one of the most beloved classic cocktails. With its simple yet flavorful mix of sugar, bitters, and bourbon, the Old Fashioned continues to evolve, but the heart of this drink remains constant: a quality bourbon. Whether you're a seasoned mixologist or just looking to craft the perfect Old Fashioned at home, choosing the right bourbon is crucial.
Here’s a quick rundown of what we’ll cover in this guide:
- The history of the Old Fashioned cocktail and why it’s still popular today.
- The classic method to make an Old Fashioned, plus some popular variations.
- A deep dive into 8 bourbons for crafting an Old Fashioned including key flavor notes and pricing.
The History of the Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned dates back to the early 1800s, where it was often referred to as a "whiskey cocktail." As bartending evolved, so did the variations of drinks, and the Old Fashioned name arose as a way for patrons to request a cocktail prepared in the original, or “old fashioned,” style. Over the years, this simple concoction of whiskey (often bourbon), sugar, bitters, and water has remained a symbol of timeless sophistication.
Its rise in popularity can be attributed to its bold flavors and its ability to highlight the characteristics of the chosen bourbon. From the smoky, barrel-proof bourbons to high-rye variants, the Old Fashioned has adapted to each generation’s palate without ever losing its core appeal.
I. Crafting the Perfect Old Fashioned
A. Classic Method
To make a classic Old Fashioned, start with a sugar cube (or simple syrup), a few dashes of Angostura bitters, and a splash of water. Muddle until the sugar dissolves, then add a large ice cube. Pour in 2 oz of bourbon and stir until well-chilled. Garnish with an orange peel and a cherry if you like.
B. Popular Variations
Some popular variations include swapping out bourbon for rye, adding a dash of orange bitters, or even using smoked ice cubes for a modern twist. Another option is using barrel-proof bourbons for a bolder flavor.
II. 8 Must Try Bourbons for Crafting an Old Fashioned
A. Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon
With its high proof and robust flavor profile, Wild Turkey 101 delivers rich caramel notes and a spicy finish, making it a fantastic choice for an Old Fashioned. Its boldness stands up well to the bitters and sugar, creating a balanced drink.
- Price: $29.99
B. Maker’s Mark
A softer, wheat-based bourbon, Maker’s Mark offers a smooth and slightly sweet flavor profile. Notes of vanilla and caramel come through beautifully in an Old Fashioned, making it a versatile pick for any occasion.
- Price: $24.99
C. Buffalo Trace - Our Personal Choice
Known for its balanced flavors of vanilla, caramel, and spice, Buffalo Trace is a staple bourbon for classic cocktails. It’s an approachable bourbon with depth, making it ideal for crafting a well-rounded Old Fashioned.
- Price: $34.99
D. Woodford Reserve
Woodford Reserve is a rich and full-bodied bourbon that shines in an Old Fashioned. Its notes of dark fruit, vanilla, and a hint of spice pair perfectly with the sweetness of the cocktail. The balance of flavors in Woodford makes it a go-to for bourbon enthusiasts.
- Price: $34.99
E. Four Roses Bourbon
If you’re looking for a bourbon with a high-rye content, Four Roses Bourbon is a fantastic pick. Its slight spiciness, paired with fruity undertones, adds complexity to an Old Fashioned, creating a drink that’s both refreshing and bold.
- Price: $19.99
F. Eagle Rare
On the pricier side, Eagle Rare is an excellent choice for those looking to elevate their Old Fashioned. Aged 10 years, this bourbon offers rich notes of toffee, orange peel, and a hint of cocoa, making it a luxurious option for your cocktail.
- Price: $84.99
G. Elijah Craig Bourbon
For those who love a bourbon with depth, Elijah Craig Small Batch brings forward robust flavors of caramel, oak, and spice. It’s a well-balanced bourbon that plays nicely with the sugar and bitters in an Old Fashioned.
- Price: $27.99
H. Larceny Bourbon
A wheated bourbon like Larceny offers a smooth and mellow experience. Its slightly sweet flavor profile, with notes of butterscotch and honey, makes it a delightful addition to an Old Fashioned, particularly for those who prefer a softer drink.
- Price: $24.99
Conclusion
Crafting the perfect Old Fashioned starts with selecting the right bourbon. Whether you prefer the bold, high-proof punch of Wild Turkey 101 or the smooth richness of Eagle Rare, each of these bourbons brings something unique to the table. Experiment with different flavor profiles, and don't be afraid to try a barrel-proof option if you're looking for a stronger kick.
With these 8 bourbons for crafting an Old Fashioned, you’re well on your way to mastering this timeless cocktail. Explore the full range of bourbons available at The Barrel Tap, and elevate your cocktail game today!
